I need to say a few things.
Over the weekend, there was a tweet announcing that Google was going to provide "scholarships" to qualified women to attend JSConf.eu. There was then a tweet by another person calling this "disgusting" and "illegal." Nicole Sullivan has a level-headed and well-articulated roundup of the back-and-forth and some of the surrounding issues, and I suggest you read it.
I take no position on the scholarships. I question whether they will have any meaningful or lasting effect. I fear the availability of the scholarships will lead to ill feelings about the women who do attend. Simultaneously, I yearn to discover, against hope, that they make it possible for some highly qualified but unknown woman to gain access to the JavaScript community. Whatever. Smarter people than me have a better idea than I do as to how effective they will be, and lawyers can tell you whether they're illegal. I'll stand firmly in the "no" camp on the disgusting count.
You know what's disgusting? Being groped at a conference after-party by a drunk married man. Opening your hotel door to discover said drunk married man stumbling down the hall, asking himself into your room, and literally having to slam the door in his face. Having a video of you posted on the internet, suggesting that you were engaged in a sexual act with the yayQuery logo. Seeing someone ask, publicly, on Twitter, if anyone knows the name of the hot conference chick. That, dear reader, is disgusting.
I adore my male friends in the tech community. They have encouraged and supported me and welcomed me into their inner circles. But even they can act like 12-year-old boys sometimes, and while I don't begrudge them that, it is hard, because it's at those moments that I realize how much I am not them, how much I long to have more than the barest assembly of female peers who have any idea what this is like. And then I remember: those peers I long for will have to put up with so much shit to be in that cool kid's club, and you know what? If Google wants to pay them a measly few hundred bucks to put up with it, maybe that's OK. Hell, maybe they ought to pay them more. Perhaps, as ham-handed and questionably productive as the scholarships may be, it's only fair to pay women to look the other way when some asshole treats them like a thing instead of a person.
I am angry. I have been angry since Saturday, when this all started. I have spent the last year trying to be the thing that I want to see: the woman on stage. I have formed groups to encourage other women to do the same. I have reached out to women who show potential and tried to give them the encouraging nudge they need that no one really gave me. And right this very moment, I feel incredibly selfish. This weekend reminded me what I am asking those women to enter into: a world that presents no tangible barriers, but that will objectify them every step of the way. And if these women have the guts -- well, let's be community-appropriate here -- if they have the balls to speak up and say that it is hard to be a woman in this field, that it takes a thick skin and determination and a willingness to be one of the boys even when that's the last thing in the world they want to do, then they should brace for a chorus of men to rise and tell them they are wrong.
Men, guys, boys: I am not asking you to give up Star Wars and The Matrix. I'm not even asking you to give up gratuitous phallic references and #twss jokes, though I hope we're all grown-up enough to know that there's a time and a place. And you know what? If you want to DM your friend about trying to hook up with that hot conference chick, well, good luck with that. We're all human. But for the love of all that is good: this being a woman in your world thing, it's not easy, OK? Maybe you can't understand it, and I even believe it when you say you don't mean it. But when you deny it, you just look like an ass.
45 comments
I regret that I didn't catch the scholarship "furor" while it was happening or I would have backed you up all the way. My workplace is perhaps better than most, the doods I work with (yes, the developers at Digg are 98% guys) are good guys and respectful of women for the most part, but they (we!, I'm not immune to the desire to fit in, as enlightened as I like to think I am) occasionally engage in sexist "humor" and the choice of bonding activities is more likely to be a first-person shooter on the 30" monitors than something more appealing to the "fairer sex." Is this the end of the world? No. But, it does create an environment that is less inclusive than it could be.
We're all on a journey. It's sad and infuriating at the same time to me to see men speaking about these issues from their blind spots. It takes a lot to admit you're part of a problem like creating a hostile environment for women in the workplace. I admit I've been that guy on occasion. The best we can hope for is that people open their eyes over time and come to view each other through a more varied lens than sex & gender.
This whole thing reminds me of the classic slogan: "Feminism is the radical notion that women are people." (By the way, women can be guilty of diminishing their value as well, especially in tech.) It's time we all, men and women, became better feminists!
I don't quite understand the fixation on quantitative equality in an industry such as ours because, quite simply, computer science appeals less (on an aggregate scale) to women for a reason. I don't think it's as simple as the barriers presented in the industry itself, but rather the stereotypical upbringing of a girl in this technological age. There is inherent inequality in so many of the things we take for granted and fully accept. Anything from wearing a pink dress to being separated from the opposite gender in school. The thing is: there is so much happening in the world that perpetuates the segregation between genders.
I guess what I'm trying to say is: the cause of the inequality/discrimination in this industry cannot be found within the industry itself. It's an external factor that needs to be fought externally and not within the confines of a industry-specific conference.
Frankly, when someone's a jerk to me, I attribute it to their general lack-of-decency and immaturity. I wouldn't think it fair to paint a group with one brush due to a few idiots.
The jerks that you encounter might just be bigoted misogynistic ass-holes. The fact that they're web developers/designers is totally irrelevant, because it's not a causal factor in their lack-of-respect/decency.
This is all just my opinion of course.
I think it's brave of you (any anyone else) to share the persecution that one faces under the unfortunate circumstance of discrimination, -- from any person it requires courage. I hope that my comment hasn't seemed too offensive or patronising -- my opinion is what it is.
And let it be known that I am an animal before I am a human, and a human before I am a man, and so many other things before I am a web developer.
The reason it's done is to encourage new people into the industry. While the students may not cope flack about their gender / physical appearance, they do occasionally get a bit about being a student, and because you're so young you must be a ‘n00b’.
Long of the short, while I can't exactly understand what it's like as a woman in this industry, I can get a fairly good picture of it. At the end of the day, if we don't open the industry up and welcome in both Women and Students alike, then we'll end up suffocating and choking a thriving industry. The industry will become stale because there's a chronic lack of new ideas, directions and perspectives. To add compound, out of all the people I've meet, it's often the Women and the Students who are the most inspiring and have the best ideas for a better web.
— Micheil.
I think the willingness to call each other out is the most important step towards equality. I love it when bigots are arrogant enough to open their mouths and publicly spout their ideas so that we can all hear how ludicrous it sounds. In other industries where professionals act more professionally, I think the problem will last longer because the bigots are less likely to out themselves.
Thanks for speaking up!
And... I deeply appreciate you not asking us to give up the Matrix (truly), but as for StarWars, StarWars can go to hell!
Seriously though, good for you, for not putting up with that BS
I'm sorry to hear that these things happened to you. The actions of those individuals is reprehensible. I suggest that you report them to the authorities or tell that guy's wife.
You might have noticed that us geek guys are not very good at, you know, interacting with people in general. A friendly reminder that we've crossed a line and made you uncomfortable will usually be enough to make us feel absolutely horrible and full of regret. Body language alone might not be enough for us to pick up on - since we're generally oblivious to such things.
Thank you for your persistence in the face of adversity, you rock.
Changing an "established order", no matter how thoughtlessly established, is always hard. I wish you success.
+1 with Chris Eppstein. I am sorry to hear about the events that happened to you. Those behaviors towards you are unacceptable and should be punished.
Thanks for speaking up. Thanks for being a voice in our community.
I can't tell you how many guys think it's ok, maybe even a compliment, to call us "hot chicks."
What they don't get--the experience they lack--is growing up where all you are judged on is your physical appearance.
I think the men in the tech world who think women should just "get over it" need to shut the fuck up until they take two distinct steps:
1. Read "Reviving Ophelia" COVER TO COVER
2. Walk around, in public, in a skirt, for ONE WEEK.
Then, they can come back, and intelligently discuss what it's like to be judged by your appearance first, and your SELF second.
Rock the fuck on, my friend.
Alexis
Having read your blog and enjoyed the YahQuery podcast, I'm glad the incidents of the last week haven't silenced you. Having worked as a developer for a lot of years I have to agree, the environment has it's share of jerks. I've certainly been offended and embarrassed, for myself and them, by the behavior and statements over the years. Particularly my younger co-workers, which seems especially odd in the context of this topic. My own daughter is a new Mechanical Engineer and I was keenly aware of the barrier nonsense she had to go through to continue in her education and still has to contend with in her job.
I'm not saying this as a means to shrug my shoulders and say, "Oh well, that's the way it is, what are ya gonna do...", but to say that yes, yes it is crummy. I've worked side by side with women in my career and I've always tried to show the respect and professionalism I hope to receive myself. But that is a small effort that affects a small sphere of people. Sadly, I think it will take out-spoken women like yourself to change the culture and environment, which is why I'm very happy that you haven't been silenced, and if anything, inflamed. As you are doing, stating clearly and consistently what you will and will not accept from your peers in the work that inspires you, change will happen. And we will all be better for it.
Thank you.
Will scholarships help bring more diversity into our industry? Probably. But will it remove the assholes who use sex as a weapon? Doubtful. There will always be jerks that lash out at others rather than face their own inadequacies.
I do hope, however, that your efforts and the efforts of other brave women succeed.
I'm not sure what else to say that hasn't been said here already -- except that you've got my admiration and my support if ever you need it (or want it).
- J
Additionally, the idea of persuading women to join a profession initiates discrimination in consideration of all of the protected classes. Why are men or women special. What about the other protected classes (race, color, religion, national origin, age, family status, disability, or veteran status). Heck, what about ugly people, short people, or people from idaho.
Equality is rooted in a person’s right to choose what is best for themselves (subjective). Forcing this notion of equal numbers as it pertains to gender is not better in regards to equality its actually worse if the goal is equality. The most equal thing we can do is let everyone choose for themselves. And that is what is done (at least in the US). The system is already working correctly. The fact that a particular gender makes one choice over another choice is simply part of the freedom to do so. In other words, if we get to choose subjectively then yes its possible that 9 people out of 10 might like chocolate ice cream more than vanilla. And if those 9 people happen to be females...it ridiculous to assert that there is an inequality issue because we have only 1 male that does not.
As for the behavior of men. This is a known factor, as not all men are cut from the same cloth. Its horrible what happen to you. But the reality is this is not unique to a profession. What you have describe is a symptom of human nature. I’d like to suggest that the world you describe is not the entire story. In the world in which you are speaking I know of men who believe/practice morality, equality, character, kindness, and most of all love. These men love in a manner that treats others more important than oneself. These men speak respectfully and appropriately to all people. These men honor there wives as well as women in speech and action. They follow the golden rule. These men are attending the same conferences you are attending (as we’ve both attended that same conferences I’ve personally meet these men). I promise if you take a good look, you’ll find them. In the jQuery community they are plentiful.
As for the man who treated you in such a manner. I can only offer a sincere apology on the behalf of individuals who subscribe to a higher morality.
I am struggling to see the difficulty. I have been a woman in 'their' world for over 8 years now and have had countless 'sexist' remarks (I call them jokes but perhaps I am too laid back) and men hitting on me in shocking ways but that's life in general. I do not blame it on the industry or anyone/anything for that matter.
My own father said to me recently (and he's not the first person to do so), while struggling to find work and being dead serious "How do you get so much work?.. it must be because you're a young, attractive female". It made me laugh.
It amuses me that people are so ignorant/jealous sometimes that they don't think maybe you got where you are because you're skilled. However, it certainly does not upset/anger me that they think that way. I know that I have the skills and I work hard to make sure that I do. Let them think what they want, who cares? I have nothing to prove to them. If anything, it pushes me harder to learn more and improve so maybe I should be thanking them!
And yes, women aren't as likely to shout "me me me" (me included) but you have to (to a certain extent) if you want to be known in this world. We can't just sit back and expect recognition. You have to market yourself, show belief in yourself and create amazing things otherwise you will get nowhere. Unfortunately, there aren't many women doing much of the above, or doing it well at least.
That said, I'm sure there are plenty of women out there, they're just keeping quiet and there is nothing wrong with that. Maybe they prefer it that way.
I wish us women would stop victimising ourselves and just move on. Really I do.
I'm with Mr Eppstein on this: a lot of geeks have no clue what so ever on how to act in a social setting and how to adapt their comments to the audience. I too am guilty of this, but I hope not to such a degree. This isn't a justification, merely an explanation.
The pendulum swings both ways though, in this business it might be women, but in others it's the other way around. I have friends that completely gave up on their industry of choice, just because they couldn't find a job, being male...
And the thing that really annoys me is the constant "omg a woman in tech!" being shouted by women... As long as you keep considering it abnormal, it will remain abnormal. There's this quote that sorta applies here imho, but I can't remember the exact wording, it basically comes down to "A new technology is only special until it becomes ubiquitous.", which could be interpreted as "X will only become ubiquitous when it ceases to be special."... I think.
Anyway, I'm pretty sure you are a true asset in whatever industry, I can only be happy you're in the same industry as I am. :P
Oh, gosh, I wish that were true. But in all truthfulness, the many wonderful men in my industry were NOT given the choice to enter a computer field where the technical work gives them a keen sense of satisfaction but they can be guaranteed that not a year -- and in some jobs, not a week -- will go by without having someone question their fitness for their employment simply on the base of their gender. They're not given the choice of finding jokes against their sex in technical manuals. They're not given the choice of being asked whose partner/spouse they are at technical conferences.
And, while I love the field enough to stay in it, I haven't so far been given the choice to work in the field without those constant irritations. You can help women in technology have that choice, by recognizing that what women in technology are complaining about isn't just an occasional bad apple, but an experience of pervasive sexism. You can also help by choosing not to minimize the difficulty of being on the receiving end of pervasive sexism.
Assuming that these guys did not set out that morning to be an asshole (to be fair, those people exist too), somehow they thought their behaviors were OK. Whether you, as an individual, are one of these jerks is beside the point. I strongly believe it is in the community's interest to make clear these behaviors are not, in fact OK.
It is easy to arrive at conclusions that feel true when they are based on our own background, upbringing and personal experiences. However, different people have different backgrounds and different lives and the truth for them is not necessarily the same as our own. It doesn't make their way, their observed obstacles or their pain invalid.
The most productive goal for all those who care is to listen to each other and try and have empathy for those around us. Realize that their experiences are also true.
Best part of the drivel: "If Google wants to pay them a measly few hundred bucks to put up with it, maybe that’s OK." Bribing women to put up with an unpleasant experience... now where have I heard this before ?
Sorry, this gets no empathy and no respect from me. I reserve those for the women with the decency to go to conference on their own dime instead of pushing for corporate charity and affirmative action quotas.
@Kathleen - Interesting phrasing, does not change the fact that you freely have chosen the profession you work in and this is based on subjective rational not objective.
To be clear, I believe that Rebecca has identified a real issue (which is her point). I just don't believe this is an issue specific to our profession. Or, even specifically to men. And no, Rebecca did not assert that it was. And, I am not saying that she did.
I believe the issue is more closely related to morality, society, and human nature. Pick 10 men at random, place them on an island with one women and bad things will occur. Pick 10 women at random, place them on an island with one man. Bad things (different things) still happen. The common factor is the human being not the gender. Sexism is only one type of discrimination, I'm not exactly sure why its the current focus. Yes sexism is bad. But I believe its a condition of our nature not a profession. You want less sexism .. don't address the symptoms for a fix, address the cause. And the cause is the morality of an individual not there chosen profession or gender. At any rate I really view Rebecca's message as this. Hey...these things do happen...and she is her to confirm that they do. And, if you that guy...stop it! Pretty simple!
It's great to know that my experiences in the industry are not isolated.
There's a great deal of comfort in knowing that many of our experiences are shared. Ultimately that we are not alone.
I've worked as a manager with web development companies Simplisite Business Solutions & Red Tiki for 8 years. I am the only woman in my company & always have been. I think it's hard for men to understand how we as women get objectified because it just doesn't happen to them.
Even when I meet someone new be it a client, colleague or assocaite they may say something like "You look beautiful" or "Don't you look gorgeous today" which I understand they mean as a compliment but I find it irritating that I'm being judged on my physical appearance rather than my professional expertise. That never happens to my males counterparts.
But such is life!
We are different (men & women) & wouldn't it be exceedingly boring if we were all the same?
@Alicia Weller - This is exactly the point. Not all women feel the same way as Rebecca so although I am not claiming how she feels is invalid, I certainly do not agree that it is valid for all women. That's Rebeccas experience and if she has a problem with it then she can follow the correct legal channels to resolve it. Please do not blame it on the industry, generalise how women feel in this industry or how men behave in this industry.
The last thing I want is for male colleagues to worry about what is safe to say/do around me. In a male dominated field, it'd be pretty lonely if we alienated them.
Then I had a daughter - and I became profoundly aware of the her plight. She's bright, inquisitive, roars like a lion, but is most likely doomed to be measured by her looks and capacity to play second fiddle to her man. As of her birth - my perspective has changed, and I only hope that I can somehow play some part in levelling the playing field for her.
It's a tough call, on the one hand - singling women out for special attention to redress inequality is an oxymoron - but without it, women will have to work twice as hard as their male counterparts, and work alone in a predominantly male environment - prepping the way for some decades distant future when the demographic of technology staffing becomes more balanced.
Great article
I used to work for a bank who tried to socially engineer a 50/50 gender split but they failed and gave up. They went to girls schools and spent much time and money encouraging women into IT. But when they stopped coercing started questioning girls on the subject, they discovered that girls coming out of school (and uni) generally didn't want to become software developers. Not because of any perceived bad attitudes from men in the industry, but because the job itself didn't appeal to them.
In my experience, girls who choose our industry, like @Jenna above, are well respected. She's one of the most interesting technologists I've followed on Twitter, and I like the fact that her real passion is for technology, not for stirring up gender debates.
I suspect that those girls who complain about our industry are a vocal minority who probably should never have chosen it in the first place because it's not where their passion lies.
I think it's great that when men grope you at networking events or try to force their way into your hotel room you know this isn't in linked to anything you've done. It's just a consequence of women still being an unquantifiable mystery in some situations where work gets done and connections are formed. As your circle of connections grows over time I'm sure this will happen less.
I also think it's fantastic that you reach out to and encourage other women - ultimately, this is good for both you and them. It's always good to give back.
@Jenna Smith - I hear you. That point is really important for people to understand. I suspect many women who are laid back about the sexism they encounter also feel concern about alienating men whether or not they are consciously aware of it. A concern about alienating the majority in your community when you are a minority is a really understandable fear.
I didn't actually hear Rebecca blame the industry for these issues. We all know this runs much deeper than any industry. However, that doesn't mean we need to give up hope that things can be better if we are willing to be open and honest about our experiences. There have already been tons of awesome men who have shown support for getting these things in the open. The topic here is not to assign blame. The point it to give a little insight on what it feels like for many to be objectified and party to inappropriate workplace conversations. Those individuals who are well intentioned do find this insight helpful.
2) Men have the "duty" to ask
3) If both comes together, well, there might be reproduction.
At least that's the way it works for the last couple of million years and that's why we're here, probably except those aliens that obviously exist in IT business.
Now there is another important fact:
4) Some people are idiots.
So, as long as that basic man-approaches-women-selects-behaviour, handed over to us from the apes, and deeply rooted in our genes, does not change, there are two corrolaries:
A) There will be always men who do the approaching part plain wrong or do not understand a "no".
B) Women will have to live with those idiots. Sorry for that, girls, but you can't kill them all, even if you feel like. There are way too many of them.
In other words: Dumb idiots like the guy you had to deal with on the conference exist everywhere. The same could have happened on a conference of doctors, historians, social workers, theater makers or penguin specialists. There are no more idiots amongst us IT guys then amongst the rest of the male population.
Uli
First of all are you promoting the idea of a prostitution?
There is definitely some movement on social norms needed, but I don't think they are gender or industry based.
I have been approached by women at conferences. I don't think the specific problem is based on you being objectified, but that a "what happens in vegas" mentality is allowed to exist. Not everyone goes for it, but some do. Its always awkward when the two groups meet.
I am generally considerate enough to keep the 'disgusting' conversations to a minimum with my friends here, but I have walked by a group of women saying things much more disgusting.
Maybe it is worse in an (this) industry that has people working long hours. Based on a quick glance around the office there are lots of couples here, and more that the couple met here but one moved on.
Have you ever had the experience where you create something really cool, or you figure out a solution to a problem that has been bugging you for a week and when you tell your wife/husband/etc you get a completely blank stare. I can't blame people for trying to meet people that have the same interests they have. I can blame them for being d-bags, but that isn't industry specific.
I can't begin to understand this situation from your viewpoint.
This industry is highly competitive, and typically has a very analytical mindset. As a result we typically call each other out on our bullshit and mistakes. Does this create best friends? Nope. Do we feel stupid and humiliated when we get called out? yup. Is it personal? It sure seems like it is, but it isn't.
Would trophy's for everyone on the team help? Nope.
If you came and worked for me yes I would attempt to judge to see if you were qualified to do the work. Just as I would for anyone. Having just finished this morning writing a VI (FTP and SCP too!) tutorial for someone to be able to do part of my job that I am no longer allowed to do, I feel very resentful towards people who I feel are useless. I resent the guy on my team who always commits code that breaks the build. I resent the guy who always uses some random naming convention.
So yeah, I will judge you to see if you can hack it. But it isn't because you are a woman.
But you wouldn't have gotten where you are if you couldn't hack it.
I am sure Leah Culver is smart too, hell she is doing crap loads better than me, yet I remember reading a post by her a while back (quick search didn't find it) in which she needed help with rounding numbers using strings or something. Did she deserve the crap she got? maybe, maybe not. Have I run into dumber things? yup.
Would a man have been crapped on as bad for something like that? definitely.
All in all I'm sorry that you have experienced those disgusting situations. Do i think google is right for giving out scholarships/bursaries. yes. Should it maybe be widened to include those that don't have the means to get there on their own for whatever reason? I think so, but they can spend their money however they want.
As a white male I generally have enough opportunities automatically, but it feels terrible when you get shafted based on something you can't change. It feels terrible when the local university gives out 2 free-ride scholarships to each HS but having the second best GPA in the school isn't good enough because the one person better than you is also male.
The "bad apples" thing wasn't by far an argument against your point, I'm just saying be careful you don't start generalizing, because then you're not much better than they are. And I'm not saying you are generalizing, just be careful.
I'm a pretty shy and introvert guy, but if I were to see something like that happen, even if it is to a woman I totally don't know personally, I would seriously have to refrain myself from confronting the guy, even if he is twice my size. Because if you don't, it's pretty much the same as saying "it's OK, go ahead".
I was out with a couple of friends a few weeks back, and this big, scary, black guy slapped one of the women in our gang on the ass. None of us noticed, and I was so pissed she only mentioned it after we left, after there was no chance of confronting the guy about it anymore. Seriously, when fucked up shit like that happens, you need to call it out, preferably really loud in a big crowd, you'll see him being reduced to a pathetic pile of retardation. And you seriously shouldn't be afraid of doing so, you'd be surprised of how many people, whom you don't even know, will instantly back you up.
I've seen you talk both at the triangle Refresh and at a day jQuery conference, and I have to say I really admire you. Not because you're a competent female technologist, though you certainly deserve props for that too, but because you put yourself out there.
I find that the only way I can continue loving what I do is to remain as isolated as possible. I have a great web app development job with respectful colleagues with whom I really enjoy working. I quit Twitter as soon as it grew beyond a tool to bounce thoughts off your immediate circle, I refuse to publicly blog about technology, and I go out of my way to avoid being the only girl at the conference/user group/whatever. I don't network like I might because of the price tag I am not willing to pay -- the more visible you are in this industry, the more you can expect this kind of piggish behavior.
It shouldn't be that way, and I am not proud of admitting that the way I deal with our shared problem is to refuse to engage in the struggle. This is the source of my admiration for you, and while predictably, this is the kind of thread that I would ignore in the interest of not getting pissed off, I felt like at least that much should be said. Seeing you talk has made me think twice about being more engaged in the community, and I'm sure the number of women who silently root for you is larger than you know.
Unfortunately, this thread does an excellent job of highlighting how deeply rooted this problem is in our field. It's really disappointing to read so many men claiming that they understand what it's like to be a woman in technology. Unless the shrinking numbers of women in computer-related fields can be attributed to massive amounts of gender-reassignment surgery by disgruntled women desperate to be treated like their male counterparts, this is a logical contradiction.
Luckily for all, truly understanding the problem is not necessary for being sensitive to the problem. We all have our personal struggles and frustrations; contrary to some assertions by previous posters, most of us are not looking for any kind of special treatment. What we do seek is this: a baseline of professional respect. Assuming that that a person's struggles are so simple as to have an obvious solution is pretty much the opposite of that.
This hasn't happened just once. Or twice. And i did have an actual relationship with one of these jerks, who misrepresented facts -- yeah, these things happen But this is crazy! All of the guys? I'm from the rock world & even there, people behaved better. One of the guys & I discussed it, and he learned from it, changed his behaviour. There are women developers pulling this crap, too.
I'm worried about this industry. If Zeldman, Meyer, Resig, etc speak out maybe people will listen. I've been harping on this and become a magnet for young, idealistic folks -- even asked to be on an ethics panel.
I typed this on my iPhone. I hope it makes sense.
That's obviously not to say that bad things are not happening, but as I cannot easily recognize the picture painted I'm wondering if this is mainly a US thing. If that's the case, I would be more interested in why the culture+industry mix creates such a bad work-environment (or, alternatively, attracts such an amount of idiots) there as opposed to other places instead of trying to pin everything on "the industry".
@Kathleen:
"But in all truthfulness, the many wonderful men in my industry were NOT given the choice to enter a computer field where the technical work gives them a keen sense of satisfaction but they can be guaranteed that not a year — and in some jobs, not a week — will go by without having someone question their fitness for their employment simply on the base of their gender."
In Denmark, if you're a guy working with daycare, the lynchmob will knock at your door first if anybody as much as thinks "pedophilia". No, it's not just women that have their skills/job-fitness questioned. It would be a great thing if we could look past the industry to the more fundamental problem of how to achieve recognition and acceptance of each other as equals, whatever the industry. Otherwise we're fighting symptoms, not the actual cause.
@Ella:
" I think it’s hard for men to understand how we as women get objectified because it just doesn’t happen to them."
Right, because it doesn't happen in women-dominated industries, at all, anywhere? This isn't a problem limited to IT and it's not a problem only for women - in more than one way: the fact that there *is* a problem is as much something to work on for men as for women - it is first and foremost a problem for society, something that everyone needs to work on fixing.
I want to quote your post in my blog. It can?
And you et an account on Twitter?
as someone who finds the boys club of engineering a bit weird, some of us men do find it frustrating that its so hard to change.
if this was a code problem everyone would be scrambling past each other for an ideal solution. but its a social problem and, well, we're just not as conscious of those as we should be.
If you have friends or family who have been working as stewardess, receptionist, waitress, bartender or such the story in your article is an absolute joke to them given what they are facing constantly and they have learned to anticipate or control this over time if not during their teen years for some of them.
As a guy working in IT myself, I have never seen a woman in IT discriminated due to her gender, quite the contrary, guys tend to be very supportive to women on a general basis and they forgive way more compared to a guy. Personally I appreciate the fact that just having a woman in a meeting can be enough to change the way males behave. Like everywhere there could be exceptions, I have heard of some but never ever encountered anyone who suffered from it.
I find women complaining about sexual behavior of their male colleagues often to not realize really what is going on the opposite way. To mention only a few events, in the last couple of years:
- In a recent business trip, I was at a bar talking to a woman and her friend I just met there, and after 2 drinks, the one I was talking to, leaned on me, kissed me and she asked me to take her to my hotel room. That was some serious direct approach.
- I was asked out more than by one of my (female) senior manager. I refused to get into this as I know fairly well the consequences that it can have in the workplace but nonetheless we remained good friends and had good relation through our time in the company, but she sure was insistant...and very friendly.
- I was asked by a female colleague working in another department literally, to 'come to my place this week end, I want you to f* me'.
- A colleague sent out a naked picture of herself to several people (incidentally males) in the company, supposedly by accident, but in any case some of us were left in shock following that, as it wasn't really a pretty sight.
I have more stories in the workplace, but nonetheless, in all these cases above, the gender situation would have been reversed, it would have created all sort of screams, disgust, and what not about males being some kind of perverts and objectifying women.
While I enjoy a bit of attention, I get also disgusted by women I consider as 'gross', and certainly do not follow all offers, even if they are done by attractive women (I may sometimes regret it much later but that's another story).
On the other hand, I certainly do not consider women that are direct as sl*ts or perverts or anything negative. They are entitled to express themselves too and this does not really bother me most of the time.
Also, I would certainly *never* confront someone publicly like a poster mentioned, there is no reason to do so, and I personally think it could make things much much worse in a very insidious way. Human nature is such that being humiliated publicly can really reveal the worse traits of the human nature, and you never know where this can lead.